Twenty dollars for the holidays
What is your plan?
Life-skills · Practice · Grades 3 to 5
Chapter 1: Money
Decide where it goes before it goes.
These are pretend situations for practice. Real money decisions belong to your family.
There is often more than one good answer. Pick one and see what happens.
Twenty dollars for the holidays
What is your plan?
The name for what you just worked out.
A spending plan is a decision you make before the money is in your hand. That is the only difference between a plan and a guess.
If you have $20 and plan $10 to save, $8 to spend and $2 to give, that is $20. If your parts add to more than you have, it is a wish, not a plan.
Changing a plan on purpose is fine. What causes trouble is having no plan and finding out afterwards where the money went.
These ones do have right answers.
1 of 2
You have $15. Your plan is $10 to save and $8 to spend. Does the plan work?
2 of 2
You have $30 and plan to save half. How much is that?
Two questions, then you are done.
Question 1 of 1
What makes something a plan rather than a guess?
Something to do away from the screen. Nobody is checking.
Why: Comparing the plan with what happened is where the learning is, not in the plan itself.
For a grown-up: Resist correcting the split. An unhelpful plan teaches faster than a good one imposed.
Save-spend-give is the standard three-jar model and its value is not the giving; it is that the child sees the whole amount divided before any of it moves. The division is the lesson.
Watch for a plan whose parts exceed the total. Children rarely check the sum because the plan feels like a wish list, and the fix is to add it up out loud rather than to say the plan is wrong.
Let a bad plan run once. A child who spends everything in week one and has nothing in week two has learned something no explanation delivers.